Last night, the Student Government Association at Florida State University reinstated funding of the Christian Legal Society chapter at FSU's law school.
Earlier this month, the student government froze funding already allocated to the chapter on the ground that it "discriminates" on the basis of religion and sexual orientation because it draws its leaders and those who select them from among those to voluntarily profess faith in Christ and strive to comply with certain conduct standards. Homosexual rights activists had sought the revocation of funding.
A media account of the original suspension of funding is here.
Thursday, February 28, 2008
FSU Reinstates CLS Chapter Funding
By Greg Baylor at 12:29 PM 0 comments
Categories Breaking News, Greg Baylor, Nondiscrimination Policies, Religious Freedom, Sexual Orientation, University Student Groups
Monday, February 11, 2008
Center Joins Comments on DHS Charitable Choice Regulations
The Center for Law and Religious Freedom has joined comments filed earlier this month regarding the Department of Homeland Security's proposed Charitable Choice regulations. Stanley Carlson-Thies of the Center for Public Justice was the principal author of the comments. The comments applaud DHS for embracing Charitable Choice principles but suggest certain additions and clarifications that would further protect religious freedom.
Friday, February 8, 2008
CLS Urges Senate to Retain SAMHSA Charitable Choice Provision
CLS today joined a letter urging the Senate to reject calls to eliminate statutory protections of religious liberty in the legislation governing the federal Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA).
The "charitable choice" provision of legislation signed in 2000 allows faith-based social service providers to participate in government-funded programs without relinquishing their religious identity. The ACLU, Americans United for Separation of Church and State, the Human Rights Campaign and others want to eliminate this protection of religious liberty. The key issue is whether faith-based organizations participating in government-funded programs may continue to take religion into account in their personnel decisions.
CLS appreciates the tireless work of Stanley Carlson-Thies of the Center for Public Justice on behalf of charitable choice and religious freedom.
By Greg Baylor at 12:18 PM 0 comments
Categories Congress, Faith-Based, Greg Baylor, Nondiscrimination Policies, Religious Freedom
CLS Urges Senate Action on Judicial Nominees
CLS today joined a letter to Senators Harry Reid, Mitch McConnell, Patrick Leahy, and Arlen Specter encouraging them to take action on President Bush's judicial nominees. The letter points out that 28 nominees are pending in the Senate Judiciary Committee.
Thursday, February 7, 2008
Federalist Society Church Autonomy Conference
The Federalist Society is sponsoring what promises to be a really terrific conference on church autonomy at Georgetown Law on March 14. Speakers include Professors Carl Esbeck and Tom Berg, both of whom advise CLS's Center for Law & Religious Freedom.
By Greg Baylor at 5:07 PM 0 comments
Categories Carl Esbeck, Church Autonomy Doctrine, Douglas Laycock, Greg Baylor
New Threat to Charitable Choice
Secular and religious liberals have asked a Senate committee to eliminate a statutory provision that protects the religious liberty of faith-based social service providers.
The statutory provisions governing the federal Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA) guarantee that religious organizations providing critical services need not relinquish their religious identity to receive government support of those activities. More specifically, the statute codifies their constitutional liberty to preserve their religious character by drawing their personnel from among those who voluntarily share their religious beliefs.
Despite the widespread legal protection and accommodation of this freedom, a group called the "Coalition Against Religious Discrimination" (CARD) claims that the exercise of this freedom is the sort of invidious discrimination that should disqualify otherwise eligible religious social service providers from participating in government-funded social service programs. CARD sent a letter to the chairman and ranking member of the Senate Committee on Health, Education, Labor and Pensions, asking them to gut the charitable choice language in SAMHSA re-authorization legislation. The language was originally approved by a bi-partisan majority and signed by President Clinton.
CARD's members include the Human Rights Campaign, the ACLU, Americans United for Separation of Church and State, and People for the American Way.
Faith-based social service providers that consider religion in their personnel decisions are more likely to be theologically orthodox or traditional. The religious and secular left understands that, and wants to de-fund their cultural opponents, with little regard to the costs imposed upon those individuals who want services from faith-based substance abuse and mental health treatment providers.
By Greg Baylor at 4:35 PM 0 comments
Categories Breaking News, Congress, Faith-Based, Greg Baylor, Religious Freedom
Monday, January 28, 2008
Ninth Circuit Issues Decision in "Choose Life" License Plate Case
The Ninth Circuit recently ruled that Arizona violated the Free Speech Clause rights of the Arizona Life Coalition by denying its request for a "Choose Life" license plate.
Congratulations to Jeff Shafer and his colleagues at the Alliance Defense Fund on their victory.
Monday, January 14, 2008
Briefing Complete in CO Student Aid Case
Briefing is complete in Colorado Christian University v. Baker now that the CLS Center filed a reply brief on behalf of CCU in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.
Colorado takes away state student aid from otherwise eligible economically disadvantaged students who choose universities the state deems "pervasively sectarian." In other words, if a poor high school senior chooses a public university, a thoroughly secular college (e.g., Colorado College), or a "less religious" university (e.g., Regis University), he or she keeps his or her aid. But if he or she chooses CCU, aid is revoked -- no matter what sort of degree the student plans to earn.
In the lawsuit, CCU alleged that the state violated the Free Exercise and Establishment Clauses of the First Amendment, as well as the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. The district court disagreed, and CCU appealed.
Eric V. Hall of Rothgerber Johnson & Lyons LLP and I prepared the brief. We expect oral argument to occur in May or September.
By Greg Baylor at 3:59 PM 0 comments
Categories Blaine Amendments, Church Autonomy Doctrine, Education, Establishment Clause, Free Exercise Clause, Greg Baylor, Religion Clauses, Religious Freedom
Friday, December 28, 2007
Strict Separationists Once Again Support Discrimination Against Religion
I suppose this is just a "dog bites man" story, but liberal strict separationist groups have once again expressed their support for government discrimination against religion.
The ACLU, People for the American Way, Americans United for Separation of Church and State, the American Jewish Congress, the American Jewish Committee, the Anti-Defamation League, and the American Federation of Teachers have together urged the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit to uphold a district court decision that nothing in the federal Constitution stops Colorado from revoking college tuition assistance from those students who choose to attend Colorado Christian University. That revocation is based upon the state's conclusion that CCU is "too religious," even though it is an accredited four-year liberal arts institution that offers majors in computer science, business administration, and numerous other "secular" fields of study.
It matters not to these groups that Colorado financially assists students majoring in the same subjects at secular, public, and less religious institutions. It matters not that the state conducts an intrusive and subjective analysis of a college's religiosity in determining whether to revoke aid to its students. So much for "separation of church and state."
The bottom line is that these groups disagree with the theologically conservative Christian worldview that underlies the educational experience at CCU. They are comfortable with forcing religiously conservative taxpayers to support students at secular and "mildly" religious universities, because the education there is more consistent with their own worldview. But they cannot tolerate allowing economically disadvantaged students who choose CCU to keep their assistance.
Religious liberty is supposed to be about government neutrality towards religion. In the eyes of these groups, church-state law is simply a tool, to be used for marginalizing their ideological opponents.
By Greg Baylor at 2:53 PM 0 comments
Categories Education, Free Exercise Clause, Religion Clauses, Religious Freedom
Wednesday, December 26, 2007
What Will the Next President Do With the Faith-Based Initiative?
President Bush's Faith-Based and Community Initiative was designed to remove obstacles to the full participation of faith-based and community organizations in federally funded social service programs. Although Congress failed to enact much legislation implementing the initiative, the Bush Administration changed many of the rules and regulations governing the relationship between federal agencies and faith-based social service providers. For example, President Bush issued Executive Order 13279, which required federal agencies to respect the faith-based hiring practices of religious contractors.
The next president will be free to rescind or modify this EO 13279 and the other regulatory changes the current president made. I am aware of no good reason to think that any of the Republican candidates would un-do these positive developments. The real question is whether any of the Democratic candidates would do so. It appears that a majority of congressional Democrats oppose protecting the faith-based hiring practices of religious government contractors and grant recipients. Therefore, it is reasonable to speculate that most if not all of the Democratic presidential candidates hold the same view.
It is conceivable that the next president might add "sexual orientation" to the list of characteristics upon which federal contractors and grant recipients may not rely in choosing their personnel. It is conceivable that there will be no exemption for religious employers, many of whom consider extramarital sexual conduct in their employment decisions. Such a move would be an unwelcome development for theologically conservative social service providers seeking to participate in government-funded programs.
By Greg Baylor at 2:43 PM 0 comments
Categories Faith-Based, Greg Baylor, Nondiscrimination Policies

